Steel Piers VS Concrete Piers?

There is an argument to be made for why each is better than the other, but it all depends on what you and your home actually need or desire. As a consumer, it is best to do your homework on which is better for your needs and study your options. There are pros and cons to both the concrete and steel piers. Both can hold a tremendous amount of weight… but the difference is in the length of time. But first you must understand factors that contribute to having foundation problems.
Causes of Foundation Problems:

  1. North Texas Soils: Typically, our North Texas soils are made up of thick, alkaline clay that holds a large amount of water making it easily expandable; thus, our soils tend to shift and move often. Our soils change with our weather conditions. It expands in the dry, hot summers, and retracts in the cold, wet winters. It is this movement that causes most of the foundation problems that we experience. The unpredictable weather patterns ranging from drought to downpours only exacerbate the movement of the soils.
  2. Large Trees: You might be surprised to learn that a large oak tree may drink up to 150 gallons of water per day! The trees close to your home have branches that are reaching below your home to find their water, and causing the moisture level under your home to decrease dramatically. This depletion is the moisture will easily cause your home to shift and move.

If you have questions, ask MSU Foundation about using steel piers vs. concrete piers. We service the Dallas, Fort Worth, Texas area. If you’re having foundation repair, review the pros and cons of both. It’s best to study your options before making a decision.

Why Choose Concrete Piers or Steel Ones?
The reason both are good choices is because they are both capable of carrying a tremendous amount of weight. Concrete is heavy and solid, steel last virtually forever and that’s important when it comes to your homes foundation. You’ll want to understand the differences. You’ll realize that concrete has been used for centuries because it has so many applications. Steel is one of the best materials ever manufactured. See for yourself why concrete piers work. Or, if steel piers are of interest, find out more.

Which Piers for Foundation Repair?
Both types are good so it’s hard to say which piers would be the best choice for your homes foundation. Deciding between concrete pilings and steel foundation piers isn’t easy. It really depends upon your situation. If you’re not staying in the same house for a long time, why pay to install steel pilings when repairing your foundation? And, if the soil in your area isn’t remarkably deep, concrete piers will be just fine. In fact, they might be the better structural foundation support to use. Most Dallas, Fort Worth area homeowners ask us to use concrete piers vs. using steel piers for foundation repair because they’re less expensive. MSU Foundation can also install them to what is called “the point of refusal,” too. Because the depth they achieve is generally between 12-15 feet, that’s far enough in most regions. Piers that are made of steel may be needed in areas when the soil is 22′ deep. That’s why it’s hard to say which is best and which is worst. There are lots of advantages to using both types of foundation piers. The question of whether to use steel piers vs. concrete pilings is something foundation repair contractors like MSU Foundation is asked a lot. The answer depends on a lot of things, and that’s why you need to review the advantages of one vs. the other. Because foundation piers are generally warrantied, if the piers do move or shift, they can be adjusted.

Pros and Cons of Steel Piers:
These supports offer advantages because they can be driven deeper into soil. Steel piers can be pushed up to 75’ into the soil, until they reach solid bedrock. This is important when installing them under your foundation in this area. You’ll learn that steel piers have several great advantages over concrete piers. Some foundation repair contractors swear they’re the best. Because steel piers can be installed very deep, vs. concrete piers which aren’t, Dallas, Fort Worth property owners sometimes do choose the steel supports. Ask MSU Foundation to tell you more. It pays to study how soil affects them and know the advantages and disadvantages of both. The movement is particularly troublesome in the upper layers of the dirt. Because steel piers are installed so deep into the ground, they are not as affected by the soil movement as other types of foundation piers. That’s one distinct advantage and reason why many people think they’re best. In addition, steel piers can support more weight. At MSU Foundation, we’ll be happy to tell you all about them.

The primary disadvantage of installing steel pilings is their cost. That’s without a doubt the worst thing about them. As a result, the majority of property owners in local area cities choose not to use these foundation supports. Steel costs considerably more to manufacture than concrete. Another one of the few disadvantage is this: If the steel piers aren’t pushed all the way down, they can move. This is a problem which can cause issues and that’s why you should consult with MSU foundation before repairs are made. It’s critical that steel foundation piers are installed to a depth where they reach bedrock or solid strata that can support the load. If it’s a case of steel piers vs. those made of concrete, inquire at MSU Foundation about it. Protecting your Dallas, Fort Worth house or commercial structure is important so get lots of information.

Pros and Cons of Concrete Piers:
Pilings made of concrete offer many advantages, too. One big benefit is that they don’t cost a lot and that’s important to everyone. Fact is, piers manufactured from concrete are far less expensive to make than pilings made of steel. That’s one reason that these foundation piers cost a lot less.
Of course, concrete piers have a few disadvantages, too. For one thing, they can’t be installed as far into the ground as steel piers when performing foundation repair. That’s considered to be one of the disadvantages of these pilings. So when it comes down to deciding on steel piers vs. concrete piers, you’ll have to remember that most areas in and around Dallas and Fort Worth don’t have extremely deep soils so it’s not a major issue. You’ll find out that they both have superior qualities, and will need to figure out which of the two types of foundation piers to use, and which will work better for your particular type of foundation. As with anything, there are many advantages and disadvantages.

In summary,
Take your time, and ask yourself some of the following questions to help you decide:
      How long do I plan to live in this home?
      Is spending a more money on steel piers now worth not dealing with this issue again?
      How do the warranties with all of the companies compare?
      Historically, what type of soil is underneath my home?
      Do I live in an area that is constantly trying to move or shift?

And then look at your options:

Concrete Piers:

Pier 1
Pros:Concrete is strong and is less expensive than steel.
Cons:Won’t hold the home in place as long because they are still placed within the expansive, clay soils. We offer a Free Transferable 10 Year Limited Warranty.




Steel Piers:

Steel Pier Pic
Pros: Steel last forever and can reach a depth greater than a concrete pier, and even surpass the moving soils under the home. It also comes with a Free Transferable Lifetime
Cons: Steel piers cost more than the concrete piers.